Duel of printers: Canon vs Epson
In connection with the technological progress of our time, we can observe a huge number of innovations in the market for printing equipment. World renowned manufacturers strive to be the best among their competitors. They improve and release more and more modernized models of printing devices. Some of these world famous manufacturers are Canon and Epson. Both brands have been competing with each other for many years and are very popular among users.
Let’s take a look at the main differences:
|Uses piezoelectric printing technology. It is based on the interaction of piezoelectric elements, membranes and current through which the paint directly enters the paper. Plus, there is no temperature difference in this technology. This allows a variety of inks to be used and the droplet volume is controlled by the amperage. The service life of such a head is increased and is equal to the service life of the device. The disadvantages include the financial side, since the piezoelectric head, in comparison with the thermal jet, is less budgetary.||Uses bubble printing technology. It provides for heating the temperature of the paint to 400⁰C and the formation of bubbles, which directly push the paint out of the nozzles. The main advantage of this technology is low cost and SIMpler manufacturing. And the disadvantages include temperature drops, which reduce the life of the printhead and equate it with consumables.|
|Benefits of Epson printers in the above piezoelectric head. Due to the lack of heating, the technology allows the use of different types of ink, which makes it universal and eliminates breakage. Plus, the 1.5 pl drop volume allows you to work with Photographic ink and print the smallest details of high quality. Epson Variable size technology allows you to control droplet size from small to large.||The minimum ink drop size in Canon devices is 1 pl. But for pigment ink, this size may not be enough and the Printhead will clog. It makes no sense to compare the droplet sizes of 1 and 1.5 pl in Epson, since the devices operate using different technologies. But in any case, Canon is much inferior to its competitor.|
For a more detailed comparison, we have selected the SIMilar models Canon PIXMA MG2440 and Epson Expression Home XP-100. Both devices have the same pricing policy with a difference of 100 rubles.
Both devices are great for small office or home use. Convenient flatbed scanner on two devices has a resolution of 1200×600 dpi. This will provide you with crisp, high quality prints. Epson’s dimensions are 390x 300×145 mm with a weight of 3.9 kg, and in the Canon 444x329x153 mm it is 5.3 kg.
The print resolution is significantly different and Epson wins this round with a resolution of 5760×1440 dpi. Together with the print head, such a device will allow you to print professional-quality photos. But the competitor lags a little behind with a resolution of 4800×1200 dpi. His pictures will be less bright. Comparing the speed characteristics, you can see a big difference, since Epson is capable of printing up to 20 pages per minute, and its competitor is only 7.
Both devices are equipped with a 4-color paint system. Our leader Expression Home XP-100 has separate colors, which greatly SIMplifies the installation of CISS. Its competitor, the PIXMA MP230, is equipped with two cartridges containing only 3 colors.
Below is an overview of THESE two models. We hope our article was useful to you. The choice is yours!
It will be about the chemical composition and whether not the cost of using ink for the printer, rather, the ability to choose consumables.
Epson. Let’s briefly return to the properties of the print technology and the drop size. With piezoelectric printers, you can use different types of ink and are not afraid of breakage, as they will not heat up. In addition, the throughput of the nozzle, calculated for a drop of 1.5 picoliter, will cope with both Photographic and pigment inks, although the number of cleanings will have to be increased. This makes Epson printing devices more versatile.
Canon. Almost all more or less modern printing devices of this company use a drop volume of 1 picoliter. For pigment inks, even though they are designed for thermal inkjet printing, a hole for this volume will not be enough. Once the printer decides to use the smallest drop for this photo, the irreparable begins. After just a few prints, the print head will clog. Alternatively, you will be able to replace it with small financial losses, but you did not want to risk it again. So, in terms of ink usage, Canon printers are inferior to their opponent.
Epson. Here, the main, but not the only criterion is size. The company was able to achieve an ink drop volume of 1.5 picoliters. This allows fine details of images to be printed much clearer. Naturally, the smaller the droplet size, the more accurate and sharper the print will be.
But what about the printing of photographs that depict panoramas, for example, mountains? With a small drop volume, filling large areas is like using a thin marker where a thick marker is needed.
And here one more criterion appears. the ability to print with a variable drop volume. Epson Variable size technology offers alternating droplet volume from coarser to finer. The software independently determines which area to use which size. At the moment, in various models, up to 6 drop sizes can be available.
Canon. The manufacturer has achieved considerable results. The minimum drop volume in Canon flagships is 1 picoliter. But comparing droplet sizes between Canon and Epson Corporation printing devices is not entirely correct due to the difference in image technology.
Duplicate images may occur with thermal inkjet printing. You’ve probably noticed that some characters have faded twin brothers. Such a second contour is formed at high print speeds, when there are too many small droplets that do not have to be.
But although such unpleasant accidents can be repeated periodically, such print quality cannot be called a rule. As for variable volume, Canon previously had Drop Modulation technology. When an additional heating element was turned on, a smaller drop was formed. But the company abandoned it in favor of printheads with rows of nozzles of different sizes.
Is there a difference: Epson vs Canon
How will the quality of the printing device depend on the manufacturer? Few people ask themselves such a question before making a purchase. Often, when choosing a printer or MFP, we are used to being guided by the advice of friends, professionals, well, and a set of necessary characteristics. And only a part of users prefers to narrow down the range of options and decide on the brand of the future assistant.
Eternal competitors Epson and Canon will reveal their cards to us, and we’ll see which one is right for us.
Print technology and print head
Epson. The company uses the principle of applying an image, which was first used back in 1984. Piezoelectric inkjet printing It is based on the interaction of a piezoelectric element, a membrane and a current through which the ink enters the paper. This element, also called a crystal, contracts under the action of electricity, causing the membrane to vibrate and expel a certain amount of paint.
Firstly, the service life of the printer’s printing systems is significantly higher than thermal inkjet devices, since there are sharp changes in temperature. Due to this, the head was made stationary. This means that it will last you as long as the printer itself. Secondly, due to the lack of heating, the choice of ink is significantly expanded. Third, the droplet volume can be precisely controlled by the amperage.
Disadvantage. The print head is significantly more expensive than thermal inkjet sisters.
Canon. Thermal printing technology began to be used back in the late 50s. The principle became known as “bubble” because of the way ink is ejected from the nozzles. Under the influence of temperatures, which can reach 400 температурыC, air bubbles form in the ink compartment. Their appearance and pushes out the corresponding amount of paint.
The main advantage is low price and SIMpler manufacturing technology in comparison with piezojet.
But the disadvantage is the temperature drop, which makes the printing system short-lived. That is why it is almost equated with consumables, and not with the main parts of the printer. She will work well with her periodic change, but this can be a problem. There are very few people who supply and sell printheads, so finding one will not be easy. And if the printer is already out of production, then this is generally hopeless.
Epson. The company’s research is oriented in several directions. First, they fiercely struggle with installing alternative consumables on their printers.
Secondly, they try to please users as much as possible in their work with photos. One solution is the Photo Enhance program. Basically, this technology directs its strength and skill to build a color rendering, which sometimes differs from the original. Despite this, in most cases the result is worth the change. In addition, the driver determines what exactly is shown in the picture (portrait, landscape), and then “cleans” small color noise, as well as minor defects. Sometimes the program manages to “pull” more from the image than was in the picture itself. For example, the camera has NOT coped with the lighting and the shadows appear to be blotchy. They will get their natural outlines on images processed by Photo Enhance.
To help him, many MFPs use Epson PRINT Image Matching (PIM) technology, which SIMplifies the work with cameras and cameras. With a direct connection, the program tries to save all custom device settings for each shot. This means that bypassing saving to a computer, the printing device receives more information about sharpness, brightness, saturation and other settings, and then tries to reproduce all of this with the available resources. It turns out that Epson is trying to provide free photo correction services.
Canon. The company distributes its forces differently. The main priority is the fight against alternative materials. But there are not so many programs to help the user.
The Color Image Processing System (CCIPS) will help slightly improve the quality of your photo when printing. All it can do for you is to process overly light or dark areas and filter out some noise in the picture. Sometimes this can be enough. You can even say that the printing device is NOT obliged to do this at all. But since we are already Comparing, in this regard, Canon is significantly inferior to Epson.
Epson. Both completely new lines and updated models of proven series often appear on the market. The company is interested that the client finds himself a suitable device. Epson clearly distinguishes printers and MFPs in the office, home, and photo categories. The company responds to the needs of its users: need wireless printing, want more mobile services, or even a factory-made CISS? Anything you want, just choose.
Canon. The company pleases with new products not so often and, of course, not so loudly. For some innovations, the models do not keep up. And it can be difficult to determine by eye what it is: an office horse or a home assistant. The company is NOT in a hurry to expand the lineup, but only from time to time releases a new product that gets lost among the old brothers.
The bottom line is NOT as rhetorical as expected. Considering the Most Significant Criteria, Epson still gets the crown. But in any case, the criteria are different for everyone, otherwise Canon would have long been gone.
Hewlett-Packard Inc. (HP)
This giant corporation was founded on January 1, 1939 in the United States by two Stanford University graduates David Packard and William Hewlett, whose names were used in the company name.
Which printer is better: Epson, Canon or HP
Today the printing equipment market offers a wide selection of multifunctional devices and printers of different brands. The most popular of them are Epson, Canon and HP, because they maximally meet such important criteria as:
- Print technology and print head,
- Ink drop,
- Software. functionality,
- Wide range of presented models.
In this article we will figure out how the products of THESE eternal competitors differ.
Print technology and print head
Epson printing devices use piezoelectric printing technology, which is based on the interaction of a piezoelectric crystal, a diaphragm and an electric current. The current is converted into mechanical energy and pushes a drop of ink from the printheads through special holes. nozzles.
Canon and HP printers are based on thermal inkjet technology, which means that the ink heats up to 400 ° C and air bubbles form in the ink container. These bubbles push the required amount of dye into the printhead nozzles. Compared to piezoelectric, this technology is SIMpler and cheaper.
The head office of Epson corporation has been based in the Japanese town of Suva since the late 19th century. The company started with the production of Seiko wall clocks, which means “exact” in Japanese. Later, in addition to watches, the company began to produce other electronics, including printing devices for use in offices and at home.
Epson offers devices with a droplet size of only 1.5 picoliters, which allows you to obtain the clearest images with high quality printed fine details. Well, for printing panoramic images, the company has developed Variable size technology, which allows you to adjust the drop size. Software control determines what droplet size is needed in a particular case, there can be up to 6 such variations.
It is inappropriate to compare droplet sizes between Epson, Canon and HP printers due to different printing technologies. Although some Canon flagship devices have an ink drop of up to 1 picoliter.
Canon was founded in 1933 by two Japanese engineers from Tokyo with the aim of manufacturing and selling 35mm film cameras, which were not inferior to their German competitors in the quality of shooting and assembly of cameras. Since 1960 the company has expanded to the production of industrial equipment, as well as photography and printing equipment.
All modern printers and MFPs are very diverse in functionality, which support:
- Wireless connection to a computer via Wi-Fi or LAN
- Auto feed for scanning and copying
- Duplex printing
- Programmed LCD and more.
Epson models have full functionality compared to competitors Canon and HP. Taking into account individual needs, you can choose a device with the necessary functions.
Reliability of mechanics
The first characteristic that you should pay attention to is the reliability of the mechanics. Due to the mechanical component, the printer performs one or another function. continuous movement of the print head, paper pulling, its feeding. and its reliability depends on how long and smoothly all elements of technology work. In this parameter, Epson printers outperform Canon and HP, although not much.
for Canon and HP inkjet models are very decoratic compared to the cheapest Epson. Low are due to disposable printheads, which are placed on the cartridges. Thanks to this decision, it was possible to reduce the cost of the equipment itself and raise the for consumables. Replacing a set of color and black ink cartridges will cost 70% of the original printer price. Such devices DO NOT support connection to CISS, and they do not produce compatible consumables.
Epson has provided for connection to its equipment and CISS and alternative consumables due to the print head installed inside the devices themselves. Thus, allowing you to save on consumables a good amount. This is very beneficial for those who plan to print large volumes at home or in the office.
Wide range of presented models
The American company Hewlett-Packard Inc presents a wide range of popular LaserJet and DeskJet lines. The latter have full functionality: scanning, printing and copying. HP devices support CISS and wireless printing of documents. And HP Inс Advantage home printers with special cartridges can cut your printing costs by up to three times.
Canon Company Occupies the niche of MFPs and photo printers for professional and home printing. this is the Pixma line. Professional devices are supplied with an inkwell with 12 containers. For small and medium-sized offices Special MFPs of the MAXIFY line have been developed.
Epson inkjet printers and MFPs famous for the widest assortment. more than 150 models. Devices of the WorkForce line are distinguished by fast and inexpensive high-quality printing and great functionality:
- Sending faxes,
- 3 in 1 functions,
- Continuous ink supply system connection,
- Using wireless printing methods.
We compared the printing equipment of three brands on the world market using six criteria. Based on this, we can conclude that Epson technology is in the lead in many parameters. True, they are let down by consumables, but you can solve this problem by installing CISS on printing devices.
Why Stationary Printhead Matters?
ANSWER: no additional COSTS
Epson devices use the Epson Micro Piezo stationary piezoelectric printhead. Unlike thermal inkjet printheads, Epson Micro Piezo is NOT a consumable item and is designed for the life of the printer. For the user, this means no additional costs for its replacement.
Find the right device:
Epson printers with CISS which is better
In June 2011, Epson launched the six-color Epson L800 printer on the Russian market. It became the world’s first mass-produced device with built-in ink tanks instead of cartridges.
Super economical compared to cartridge models, the photo printer instantly hit the bestsellers and changed the inkjet market forever.
Bestseller since 2011.
Refilling ink. SIMple and neat
- Impossible to spill
- Impossible to confuse
An internal “InkLock” valve in genuine Epson ink containers reliably protects against accidental ink spills. The valve opens only when the container is inserted into the corresponding filling hole. As soon as you remove the container from the filling hole, the valve closes and the ink remains inside, even if the container is turned over.
In addition, each container has a unique spout shape: it fits only the color-matching filling hole on the principle of a key with a lock. “KeyLock”.
New filling system “Print Factory” Epson
Devices of the Epson Print Factory home series are as versatile as possible. They print crisp text and graphics on plain paper, and vibrant photos on photo paper.
All models of the series for the home are supplied with a set of ink, which is designed to print up to 7500 color and 4500 b / w A4 prints. 5. We print an average of 300 documents per month, the next refueling of the printer will need to be done only after 3 years! 7
25 times more profitable than cartridge devices! 3
Print a lot! The delivery set of any Epson printer and MFP of the Epson Print Factory series includes a set of full-size ink containers. Depending on the model of the device, there is enough ink to print:
- 14,000 black and 11,200 color pages 4 for Epson L61XX series office devices
- 4,500 black and 7,500 color pages 5 for Epson L31XX series home devices
- 1900 photos 6 format 10×15 for photo printers and MFPs of the Epson L8XX series.
For small office
Office models offer enhanced durability and specialized capabilities such as Ethernet network connectivity, multi-page ADF, faxing, and more. In addition, the delivery set for most devices in this category comes with a double set of ink containers, thanks to which, already from the starter set, you can print in 14,000 b / w and 11,200 color pages 4.
Another advantage is the ability to independently replace the waste ink bottle without contacting the service department.
For printing photos
Models for photo printing are characterized by the Extended color palette. Added tints to standard CMYK ink for increased gamut and contrast for photo printing.
A choice of five and six color models. The former use additional black photo ink (Water-soluble), which increases the contrast when printing photos and black pigment ink, which ensures high-quality printing of text on plain paper.
In the six-color models, additional light magenta and light blue colors are added, thanks to which the transitions of shades are smoother, and the colors are rich and saturated. The resource of one set of containers is designed for printing up to 1900 photos of 10×15 format 6.
Epson’s traditionally high print quality
It is the Printhead that is responsible for line clarity, image detail and print speed. Patented Printhead in Epson Print Factory series controls size and positioning accuracy Ink droplets on paper guarantee superior print quality.
Printed with an Epson printer
Competitors are NOT asleep
The negative ends on the inconvenience, and potentially the buyer is offered to choose the object of his desires in several price categories. Inexpensive HP OfficeJet 7110 model can be purchased for about 10,000 rubles, its print resolution is enough for home use.
What it is?
It’s no secret that all manufacturers of office equipment, without exception, make money not in the device itself, but on consumables. Any user who has purchased an inkjet printer may find that he only spent at least 100% of the initial cost of new equipment on refilling cartridges. And this is far from the limit. One involuntarily has to think about cost reduction. It will NOT work to stop printing, since the Printhead will dry out and the printer will have to be thrown away, but the thought of self-refueling will be interesting.
It is for those users who constantly need color printing, but who are also very concerned about the question of cost price, that a printer with CISS was created. And if at first the continuous ink supply system was sold separately from the printer, then over the past few years, all manufacturers of office equipment have provided customers with the opportunity to purchase a printing factory.
Photo printing without borders
However, not a single inkjet device is insured against drying the printheads, so the user is obliged to print a test page 1-2 times a week. It is not at all difficult to configure it automatically on a computer. Using the task scheduler and checking the presence of paper in the feed tray, you can ensure that the printer with CISS will self-service itself.
In the process of use, many owners have found that the printer and printheads are NOT picky about ink. Wanting to save on refueling, you can fill in cheap ink from WWM instead of branded paint. It’s a pity that an Epson printer with CISS cannot afford such a luxury, otherwise the user would have received, along with a low price and high quality, comfort, which is absent both in HP and Canon in terms of placing a continuous printing system near the printer.
Problems and solutions
It doesn’t matter which inkjet printer with CISS the users bought for themselves, as well as what price he paid for it, sooner or later there will be a problem with the impossibility of printing any color. The fact is that the continuous ink supply system is an option in the printer and as a full-fledged certified technology is absent. Banal drying of nozzles by printheads or air ingress into the system will damage the printer.
When choosing office equipment for home or office, any user is faced with a problem: what to give preference to. an inkjet system or a laser? The low cost of black-and-white laser printing is SIMply incomparable with expensive color photo printing. A printer with a CISS continuous ink supply system is designed to meet the needs of the user, which will allow high-quality color printing at virtually no cost.
Interesting models Epson
A budget Epson printer with a factory-made CISS should have not only a low price, but also a small one, including the CISS itself and ink to it. It is not worth expecting that the printer will print high-quality photos, but if there is a student in the family, such a device will be necessary.
Professional desktop printing systems supporting A3 format are more in demand in business. In addition to high-speed and high-quality printing, the device can handle a large amount of work. The entire professional “R” line from Epson has proven itself well. For example, an Epson R2000 inkjet printer with CISS can be purchased in a complete set for 50 thousand rubles.